The controversy of Christmas before Remembrance Day

For some, as soon as the clock strikes midnight on Nov. 1, “All I Want for Christmas is You” is on repeat, the Christmas tree is up, and Home Alone is the only thing on the television until January.
For others, waiting until at least Nov. 12 is a sign of respect to those who are fighting or have fought for our freedom.

With each November comes the annual debate: is decorating for Christmas before Remembrance Day disrespectful to soldiers and veterans?

Lorraine Holder is a poppy-distributor volunteer who feels Christmas has a time and place, but not until after Remembrance Day.

“We want to remember our war dead or even our heroes at that time, and Christmas is important, but Jesus has his time to celebrate and his time is usually in December,” said Holder, whose parents were both in the military.

Wearing a poppy is standard etiquette for Canadian citizens beginning in November, but sometimes they are overshadowed by the “Christmas Rush,” which also begins in November. (Lauren Hoyt/AQ)

Others believe that the freedom veterans fought for gives people the right to celebrate whenever they want.

“We’re still recognizing the people who fought, but they also fought for us to have these liberties and freedoms and so people should be able to do as they wish,” said Laura Wheaton, a St. Thomas University student.

In the retail world, the “Christmas Rush” is known to begin the final week of October. By Nov. 1, the holiday season has arrived and stores can be found decorated in red and green, with holiday products on display.

Although Christmas originated as a religious celebration, it has become the most commercialized holiday on the calendar. Stores waste no time taking advantage of this, some putting out decorations as early as August. Jack-o-lanterns still litter doorsteps while the mall is transformed into the North Pole. But it’s different for Remembrance Day.

Few stores can be found with displays of remembrance like poppies on mannequins and crosses at the checkout.

Some people even feel that decorating in early November is not only disrespectful, but it’s also just too early for Christmas in general.

“In addition to being in very poor taste, by the time Christmas finally rolls around people just want the fucking day [Christmas] over with,” said Rodger Wilkie, a St. Thomas University professor.

“The days prior to Remembrance Day are often given over to thoughtful public discourse on the sacrifices made by members of the military. Being inundated with lights and trinkets and cheap plastic knick-knacks symbolizing the most commercialized holiday in the world undermines and trivializes that sense of contemplation and awareness.”

The question receives mixed answers every year. The argument may never be resolved, but most Canadians agree that no matter when you string up your lights, it’s important to wear a poppy from Nov. 1 to 11 to pay respect to the fallen and fighting.

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

You May Also Like

Protests for Palestine: Olmert visit sparks fervent furry

Debate rages across campus after Israeli scholar offers his insight into the Gaza conflict ...

Jesus Freak

By Lee Benson What would you die for? And no, I’m not talking about ...

Idio-stu-cracy: A Narrative with the Seasons

By: Michelle MacNeil – The Aquinian The romance is over, the honeymoon holidays are ...

Love Bites

By Megan McKay I have always identified more with guys. The strangeness of that ...

Panel tackles poor literacy

By Karissa Donkin A national panel on literacy made a stop in Fredericton on ...

“When they get deployed your heart basically goes with them…”

As the war in Afghanistan stretches on, one army wife shares stories about the ...